Comments on: FON: getting going fast

By: Michael Billingsley

Michael Billingsley — Sat, 26 Nov 2005 22:19:16 +0000

Hello Antoin,
I’ve passed on Bernie’s and your comments about Fon to a friend in Bray. He’s not ultra-tech… basically a reasonably proficient keyboard and sampling composer (formerly of Dublin) and yet with a laptop could benefit when he’s at symposia in Germany, Netherlands, Spain or U.S. (Or could he, in the U.S? Does Fon get over to Canada and U.S. as yet?)
Michael B.

By: antoin

antoin — Fri, 18 Nov 2005 15:29:18 +0000

Good questions.

Yes, you could use OpenWRT and leave it completely open (which I think it is a great idea). You can even download the GPL’d FON software and hack it if you want, providing you don’t violate the trademarks.

The problem with ‘going it alone’ like this is that there is no registration at all, and there is no benefit to you as the person who is providing the hotspot. As a result, there is little incentive to drive ADSL users to share their broadband as you describe. With FON, the availability of free access when you are away from home is a good reason to deal with the system.

I don’t read German well, but Freifunk is based around meshing technology as I understand it. There are obviously similarities. I don’t really know enough about it, but I would see FON and Freifunk.de as possibly being complementary, not competitive.

You pay for your own Internet connection and the equipment. The benefit is that you get access to a network of wi-fi points for free, that you’d otherwise have to pay for. The extra cost is very small compared to the ongoing cost of a DSL line.

There is a complicated literature around your point around licences. Basically, you don’t need a licence to deal in telecomms services.

FON is a system for sharing hotspots. It is designed to give you access to broadband when you’re away from your home base.

FON is not meant to compete with WiMAX, which is designed to provide longer-haul services. It’s not about providing long-haul or last-mile. It’s definitely not about competing with existing telecomms providers.

It’s good to hear your comments. Let me know what you think.

By: Michael

Michael — Thu, 17 Nov 2005 20:09:13 +0000

Hi Antoin,
Some questions:

-Why should I use FON and not download OpenWRT (which is actually what they use) directly on my access point from the Internet?

-How do you differentiate FON from movements like Freifunk.de?

-Who will pay for the Internet connection? And for the necessary equipment to setup de FON hotspot?

-Is it not illegal to resell Internet connections without a license?

-How will you compete with existing WiMAX networks?

This is just to start with. Sorry if it´s too long but I have a lot of doubts, otherwise I find the idea pretty good, although not new at all.

Regards