in Uncategorized

IE Domain Registry – the government consults

The government has its proposals for regulating and possibly taking control of the IE Domain Registry (MS Word document containing links to relevant sections) out for consultation at the moment. Responses to the consultation have to be in before 20 January 2006. The relevant text is also reproduced at the bottom of this post.

I have now been actively involved with issues around the governance of the IE domain for longer than anyone, and my personal opinion is this. I am very sad that the Irish Internet community in general and the boards of UCD and IE Domain Registry Ltd. in particular have allowed things to end up in this sorry state where an outside regulator has to be given powers to enforce its will on the system. As a community we should get together and sort this out. We shouldn’t have to wait for the government to come in and regulate our mess for us. Government involvement will ultimately result in more red tape, slower progress during a time of rapid technological change and higher costs.

I am very concerned about how the IE Domain Registry is governed (see what I have written about the issue previously on the IE Domain Registry Ltd’s own website and on this site. I have been particularly concerned since University College Dublin, which is the body charged with operating the IE Domain delegated the responsibility to a private company under the control of a group of UCD staff, former staff and graduates without any democratic process and without any community oversight.

The operation of the IE domain by this private company (IE Domain Registry Ltd.) seems to consist of continuous antics. Only this Wednesday, a person working in the industry called me to express his concern about sudden recent changes in the way wholesale charges for domain names are structured. I don’t have all the facts available to me to determine whether this concern is justified, because all the consultations and deliberations of IE Domain Registry Ltd. are conducted completely in private, out of site of the general Internet community.

I have written to IE Domain Registry Ltd. to clarify simple questions about corporate governance and the composition of the board by email and even by registered letter, and the company refuses to even do me the courtesy of acknowledging the correspondence.

Last year, it became apparent that a member of IEDR Ltd’s staff was wholesaling domain names on his own account, at below the wholesale cost. On that occasion, the company confirmed that this was the case, but could not seem to see that this placed the company in obvious commercial conflict with its own resellers

Before that, the Registry became involved in a complex and expensive litigation in the High Court with its previous chief executive, which it eventually had to settle out of court.

The retail charges for a .ie domain name are still very high by international standards. The actual wholesale price of a domain name is kept secret from the general public. At the same time, the registry appears to be highly profitable and cash-generating.

It is very important that anyone who is involved with the administration of .ie domains or is concerned about the registry should read the proposals and consider making a submission. There is still time for the community and if possible, UCD and IE Domain Registry Ltd. to come together and sort this out. I would welcome any feedback from anyone with a view on the subject.

The relevant text from the heads of a bill in the consultation document issued by the Department of Communications, Marine and Natural Resources is as follows.

Part 5 – Regulation of the IEDR

Head 12 – Regulation of the Internet .ie Domain Name by ComReg

12.1 ComReg may by Regulation provide for:

– the transfer of powers, in relation to the regulation of the .ie domain name, vested in the Minister to ComReg

– access by ComReg to the .ie domain name database on an ongoing basis

– the creation of an offence, where the operator of the Internet .ie domain name, fails to comply with regulations introduced by ComReg.

Provide for increase of summary fine under subsection (3) of Section 31 of the above Act to €5,000.

Notes 12.1
Section 31 of the Electronic Commerce Act, 2000 provides powers to the Minister to make regulations in respect of the management of the .ie domain name. To date the Minister has not made any such regulations. The purpose of this Section is to transfer the Minister’s powers to ComReg and for the creation of an offence where the operator of the .ie domain name fails to comply with regulations introduced by ComReg. The Section also intends to provide ComReg with access to the .ie domain database to ensure that the list of registered users is at all times kept up to date and functioning on the Internet.

Write a Comment


  1. It’s been coming for the last few years. There was an effort albeit disjointed from the Internet community it was all just ignored.

    The announcement of price reductions seems a little timely.

  2. The wholesale rates and other matters that you mention were discussed with the IE resellers at length prior to being implemented.
    I don’t see how anyone could take issue with the new wholesale rates, as they now lower than ever before and uniform.

  3. Unfortunately not everyone in the business agrees with you.

    While we are on the subject, what is the wholesale price of a domain now and what was it before?

  4. Maybe they don’t agree with me, but anyone complaining is probably charging more than they really need to.


  • Lex Ferenda » Dot IE and the Communications Regulation (Amendment) Bill February 14, 2006

    […] There seems to be some confusion over the provisions in the Communications Regulation (Amendment) Bill 2007. While – as promised in the Electronic Communications (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2005 consultation (good post at the time by Antóin – the law on domain names in Ireland is being updated, very little of this is novel – and most of the sections being discussed have been on the books since the Electronic Commerce Act 2000 (Section 31), and are merely being reorganised. The 2000 Act provided that the Minister could take the .ie registry under his/her control; the 2005/6 consultation proposed substituting ComReg for the Minister. This new Bill does the same, but with slightly different wording – and that’s what’s causing the confusion. I do believe this legislation (and the process surrounding it) is interesting, but for different reasons. […]

  • Il mondo dei tld e dei nomi a dominio February 14, 2006

    Registrazione domini IE – consultazione del governo

    Il governo Irlandese ha rilasciato una proposta per la regolazione delle registrazioni di domini .IE.
    Scrive a questo riguardo Antoin O Lachtnain su